ROTISSERIE: The value of volume

Quality or quantity? Many difficult lineup-setting decisions boil down to this choice. Do you start the better hitter whose team is scheduled for five games in the coming week or the less-skilled hitter with a seven-game week? Do you roll the dice on a marginal (or worse) two-start pitcher or go for quality over quantity with a better one-start pitcher or a highly skilled reliever? While we face it most frequently in setting lineups, the quality vs. quantity question also factors into draft, trade, and waiver decisions: When making such decisions, how should we value “compilers,” whose value depends in large part on playing time volume? When and to what extent should we forego volume by prioritizing “skills over roles”?

There is of...

Almost!

You’re just a few clicks away from accessing this feature and hundreds more throughout the year that have a singular goal in mind: Winning your league. Subscribe to BaseballHQ.com here!

Already a subscriber? Sign in here

More From Rotisserie

There are plenty of young and taltented catchers as we enter the 2026 season.
Dec 11 2025 3:05am
An attempt to identify the best and most MLB-ready of both marginal producers and legit prospects with upside at the SS position.
Dec 9 2025 3:02am
Matt Shaw headlines our crop of dynasty building blocks at the hot corner.
Dec 4 2025 3:04am
We'll take a look at NL outfielders who could see big value gains over the next few seasons, as well as those that could net sharp dynasty owners huge returns as soon as 2026.
Dec 2 2025 8:00am
We kick off our Dynasty Reload series with the AL outfield. There are several interesting prospects and a couple of first-year flops (like Jac Caglianone) poised for a rebound.
FREE
Nov 28 2025 8:02am

Tools