F/F SPOTLIGHT: Andrew Benintendi
Jun 26 2019
Back in a February Facts/Flukes column by our own Robert Berger, we posed an interesting question: Is Andrew Benintendi (OF, BOS) a second-rounder?
On one hand, the answer seemed simple. Benintendi was an elite prospect—he ranked #2 overall on our 2017 HQ100—who posted roto values of $23 and $31 in his first two full big league seasons. He'd already proven his worth at the MLB level, and would be hitting near the top of a potent BOS lineup, allowing him to rack up plate appearances and counting stats galore.
But on the other hand, Benintendi was coming off a second half where his power completely evaporated (3 HR in 270 AB), leading to a somewhat tepid write-up in his Baseball Forecaster box:
According to BPX and R$, an all-around...
Almost!
You’re just a few clicks away from accessing this feature and hundreds more throughout the year that have a singular goal in mind: Winning your league. Subscribe to BaseballHQ.com here!
Already a subscriber? Sign in here
More From Facts & Flukes
William Contreras has lost value. Also: Quinn Priester, Spencer Steer, JoJo Romero, and Otto Lopez.
Aug 12 2025 3:06am
Aug 12 2025 3:06am
Shea Langeliers has always had power. Now he's added contact. Plus Christian Walker, Nathan Eovaldi, Logan O'Hoppe, and Michael Wacha.
Aug 11 2025 3:06am
Aug 11 2025 3:06am
Can Max Scherzer finish the season strong? What do the luck and skill metrics indicate for Riley Greene, Adrian Houser, Abraham Toro, and Garrett Whitlock?
Aug 7 2025 3:09am
Aug 7 2025 3:09am
Freddie Freeman's production has slowed in 2025. Also: MacKenzie Gore, Ian Happ, Jordan Roman, and Lourdes Gurriel Jr.
Aug 6 2025 3:06am
Aug 6 2025 3:06am
Alex Bregman has not slowed down since coming back from a six-week IL stint. Kevin Gausman has rebounded from his down year in 2024, but he's not back to where he was from 2021-2023. Plus, updates on Josh Naylor, the new closer Cade Smith, and Jonah Heim.
Aug 4 2025 3:06am
Aug 4 2025 3:06am
