F/F SPOTLIGHT: Andrew McCutchen

Since his debut in 2009, Andrew McCutchen (OF, PIT) has been one of the best players in the league, in both real baseball and fantasy baseball. In real baseball, he ranks third in WAR in that time, behind only Miguel Cabrera and Mike Trout. In fantasy baseball, he has posted $ values in the $25-$40 range and BPVs from 75-110.  He’s been a reliable first round pick for years.  From the 2016 Baseball Forecaster:

“Remarkably stable Eye, h%, HctX, PX, and xPX still scream superstar. His three .300/.400/.500 seasons in last four are an MLB-best; just missed the fourth. Pay up.”

2016, so far

The fantasy results have not lived up to expectations. 2016, while not without value, has been a huge disappointment. He has earned just $13 in 5x5...

Almost!

You’re just a few clicks away from accessing this feature and hundreds more throughout the year that have a singular goal in mind: Winning your league. Subscribe to BaseballHQ.com here!

Already a subscriber? Sign in here

More From Facts & Flukes

Alex Bregman has not slowed down since coming back from a six-week IL stint. Kevin Gausman has rebounded from his down year in 2024, but he's not back to where he was from 2021-2023. Plus, updates on Josh Naylor, the new closer Cade Smith, and Jonah Heim.
Aug 4 2025 3:06am
How high of a ceiling exists for Seattle's Bryan Woo?
Aug 1 2025 3:09am
Byron Buxton is healthy and producing. We'll examine the skills and underlying metrics for Garrett Crochet, Gleyber Torres, Eric Lauer, and Randy Arozarena.
Jul 31 2025 3:06am
CJ Abrams improves fantasy value. Also: Shota Imanaga, Kyle Stowers, Camilo Doval, and Tyler Freeman.
Jul 29 2025 3:06am
Will Reese Olson finish the season strong? We'll also examine the skills and underlying metrics for Brent Rooker, Slade Cecconi, Jeremy Peña, and Simeon Woods Richardson.
Jul 24 2025 3:06am

Tools