Spotlight: Tanner Bibee

An "UP: sub-3.00 ERA, 200 K" from the Baseball Forecaster, just his age-26 season, minimal injury history, and two-plus years of good stats and skills? What wasn't to like about Tanner Bibee entering 2025? 

Well, it's been a somewhat stomach-churning start for Bibee, who gave up 13 ER in his first four starts, and has seen his ERA rise to a career-high level in 2025. Let's scan the skills through our traditional Facts/Flukes lens:

SeasonIPERA/xERAWHIPH%/S%GB%/FB%Ball%BB%K%SwK%HR/FBPX
20231482.98/4.341.231%/78%36%/41%36%8%24%11.5%7%107
20241733.47/3.781.1231%/73%34%/44%33%6%26%12.8%10%143
2025803.79/4.221.2130%/76%42%/40%37%7%19%9.2%14%94

Some worrisome signs from several indicators:

  • Bibee's drop in strikeout rate is alarming, as his K%...

Almost!

You’re just a few clicks away from accessing this feature and hundreds more throughout the year that have a singular goal in mind: Winning your league. Subscribe to BaseballHQ.com here!

Already a subscriber? Sign in here

More From Facts & Flukes

Zach Neto was held back by a couple of injuries in 2025 but offers big upside. Plus, Alejandro Kirk, Jake Burger, Tanner Bibee, and Luis Castillo.
Feb 24 2026 3:09am
Can a 33-year-old Mookie Betts rebound from the worst season of his career? Plus, Wyatt Langford, Trevor Rogers, CJ Kayfus, and Tony Santillan.
Feb 22 2026 3:05am
Max Fried pitched like an ace in 2025 despite a second-half slide. Any reason for concern? Plus looks at Vinnie Pasquantino, Jo Adell, Jack Flaherty and Andrés Giménez.
Feb 19 2026 3:05am
After averaging 36 HR and a .286 BA per season from 2021-23, Austin Riley has battled injuries and hit 35 HR combined in 2024-25. Can he rebound? Plus Edward Cabrera, Eugenio Suárez, Aaron Nola, and Ramon Laureano.
Feb 18 2026 3:09am
What to expect with Bo Bichette joining the Mets. Also: Eury Pérez Michael Busch, Merrill Kelly, and Miguel Andujar.
Feb 17 2026 3:07am

Tools