STARTERS: Ten overrated SP

If you are looking to minimize your risk on draft day, it's best to avoid bidding market value on starting pitchers whose xERA were significantly higher than their actual ERA. These SP likely will be overvalued in many drafts.

In 2011, there were over 30 SP with xERA that were at least 1.50 ER higher than their actual ERA:

                            -------2011------
Name                League  ERA   xERA  Diff
================    ======  ====  ====  =====
Aceves, Alfredo         AL  2.61  4.18  (1.57)
Hellickson, Jeremy      AL  2.95  4.47  (1.52)
Johnson, Josh           NL  1.64  3.13  (1.49)
Moscoso, Guillermo      AL  3.38  4.72  (1.34)
Weaver, Jered           AL  2.41  3.68  (1.27)
Cueto, Johnny           NL  2.31  3.57 ...

Almost!

You’re just a few clicks away from accessing this feature and hundreds more throughout the year that have a singular goal in mind: Winning your league. Subscribe to BaseballHQ.com here!

Already a subscriber? Sign in here

More From Starting Pitchers

Former ace Sandy Alcantara finally looked healthy late in 2025, giving hope that he can recapture his ace-like form in 2026.
Jan 30 2026 3:05am
Nick Lodolo's return to health in September reinforced his rotation-anchor upside.
Jan 9 2026 3:05am
The underlying command gains of Cade Povich in the second half bode well for his ability to take a step forward in 2026.
Sep 6 2025 3:10am
Sean Manaea's ugly August ERA hid an impressive foundation of skills that could lead him to a much better showing in September.
Aug 30 2025 3:09am
Shane Baz's volatility can be traced back to some significant struggles against lefty bats.
Aug 23 2025 3:09am

Tools