GM's OFFICE: Evaluating our 2017 process

When he was running BaseballHQ.com, one of Ron Shandler's annual season-ending columns was "When good projections go bad," an annual exercise that served as a warts-and-all look at the hits and misses between our pre-season projections and actual results. He would run the lists here on the site each fall, and it also appears in the Encyclopedia section of the Baseball Forecaster. (Timely reminder: the 2018 edition is available for pre-order now!)

In recent years, Brent and I have taken over the compilation of this list from Ron. But we had a bit of a communications snafu in the Forecaster production process this week, where I went off to conduct this exercise, and found that Ron had already done it for me!

So, with a hat tip to our...

Almost!

You’re just a few clicks away from accessing this feature and hundreds more throughout the year that have a singular goal in mind: Winning your league. Subscribe to BaseballHQ.com here!

Already a subscriber? Sign in here

More From GM's Office

A look back at successful 2025 BaseballHQ projections for pitchers.
Oct 10 2025 3:01am
A look back at successful 2025 BaseballHQ projections for hitters.
FREE
Oct 3 2025 3:01am
The 2025 fantasy baseball season is over, but once again, BaseballHQ.com writers fared quite well in industry and expert competitions. Here's the details.
FREE
Sep 30 2025 10:09am
Our annual sorting exercise for 2025's outlying performances, the first step in trying to refine our processes for 2026.
Sep 29 2025 3:03am
We get a lot of questions about the accuracy of our Starting Pitcher Matchup Scores tool. So we spent the All-Star Break conducting a validation of the scores we posted in the first half of the season. Results inside...
FREE
Jul 18 2025 3:04am

Tools