Pirates, Phillies, Tigers, Reds, and Orioles pens

This week, the bullpens of the Pittsburgh Pirates, Philadelphia Phillies, Detroit Tigers, Cincinnati Reds, and Baltimore Orioles to see if the closer skill sets are tracking and whether a change is needed.

The Pittsburgh Pirates have David Bednar (RHP, PIT) closing and he has six saves despite a 9.69 ERA and 1.46 WHIP to-date:

PITSVHDIPERAxERAWHIPK%K-BB%HR/9
Bednar, David6013.09.693.591.4629%22%2.1
Chapman, Aroldis L1712.04.503.991.5841%14%0.8
Stratton, Hunter1117.12.603.120.8727%24%1.1
Holderman, Colin039.20.933.610.8332%23%1.0
Ryan, Ryder0312.03.004.061.0826%15%0.0

Bednar is typically better than a 9.69 ERA, and we can see his xERA is 3.59, and the K% is 29% with a 22% K%-BB%. All good. So what is with the bloated ERA and WHIP? Part of it has...

Almost!

You’re just a few clicks away from accessing this feature and hundreds more throughout the year that have a singular goal in mind: Winning your league. Subscribe to BaseballHQ.com here!

Already a subscriber? Sign in here

More From Relief Pitchers

This is the annual sleepers column, but let's be honest: There are no sleepers. There are relievers with great skills who are cheaper than they should be ... and that's what you want anyway.
Mar 1 2026 3:03am
Here are your high skills relievers projected to come at a discount and earn a profit, per LIMA grades.
Feb 22 2026 3:04am
These five pens are going to figure out roles during Spring Training. Kevin Ginkel appears to be the favorite in Arizona, but let's look at the known options from a skills perspective.
Feb 15 2026 3:07am
An early February run through closers by NFBC ADP.
Feb 6 2026 3:04am
The initial set of BaseballHQ projections is on the board, and we initially wade through it for three things: LIMA A or B+, at least a 20% K-BB%, and at least one save. Here is that list.
FREE
Jan 16 2026 3:02am

Tools